Simultaneous Election : A critical analyses why it should be? and why should not it be? - Seeker's Thoughts

Recent Posts

Seeker's Thoughts

For Clearing the Blur Spot.

Follow by Email

Simultaneous Election : A critical analyses why it should be? and why should not it be?

What is simultaneous election?
India has two government forming  direct election- first- when entire nation votes including citizens of all states and decide a leader for the Prime Minister of India. This election is called as ‘Lok Sabha Election’ or the ‘House of the People’s election’ or ‘Election for the lower house’. Elected members are called as MP or Member of Parliament.

Second types of elections happen in states at different time to elect a Chief Minister of the State. These elections are not conducted nationwide at a time. Every state has different time, and different ruling parties- That is how chief minister is elected. 
These are direct elections, and are called as elections of Vidhan sabha or election of Legistlative assembly. The elected candidates are called as MLA.
What is the issue at present? - Simultaneous Elections
The ruling party, which is NDA led BJP is pushing for simultaneous election. While opposition political parties like congress is strongly against it.
What does the Election commission say?
Election commission is a constitutional body which conducts the election.  It also says that holding these both elections together – That means Vidhan Sabha and Lok sabha in year 2019 is impossible.
The VVPAT machines are unavailable, and without VVPAT, EVM machines are often accused for conducting a fraudulent election.
A history of Simultaneous Election- The first four election during 1952 to 11967 ( 1952, 1957, 1962 and 1967) were simultaneous elections.
Congress suffered huge defeat in 7 states, under leadership of Indira Gandhi that is when the idea of simultaneous election was rejected.
Benefits of simultaneous election-
1.       Huge money is wasted in different elections as party campaigns and cost of conducting election every time.
2.      People don’t take elections seriously due to its occurrence every after three months which includes, Lok Sabha, Vidhan Sabha, Gram Panchayat, and Municipality one after another.
3.      Political leaders will focus more on progressive work because election campaign will not be burdening them.
4.      Parliamentary standing committee also recommended that simultaneous election are beneficial for India as it will reduce the cost associated with multiple elections.
5.      To overcome policy paralysis associated with imposition of Model Code of Conduct during elections.
6.      To limit the disruption of normal public life in the run-up to and during the elections.
7.      To free up the manpower of the armed and para-military forces deployed on election duties.

Federal structure will be hampered- As opposition has kept it that simultaneous election will temper with federal structure of the elections.
To implement the simultaneous election, the state government who recently has won election would have to end their term  
If Lok Sabha and Vidhan Sabha elections are held together the national interest will prevail and state interest would be neglected.
Conclusion - Overall, two points can be made. One, a dominant position at the Centre may translate into corresponding gains at the state level. Two, every state has its own power dynamics, and like earlier even if there were simultaneous elections up to 1967 yet the Congress Party lost elections even if it was the only national party.
However, the organs like election commission, their opinion about why not to conduct simultaneous election must be considered because it will be a technical failure.